The Brooklyn Nets: Whose Fault Is It?

Exterior of Barclays Center in Brooklyn, New York, home of the Brooklyn Nets, photographed in April 2026.

I am writing this article the day after Brooklyn Nets 107 – 137 Chicago Bulls, leaving the Nets with a 3-11 record from their first 14 games in 2026/2027. A 30 point loss at home to a team that in pre-season ESPN had down as only the 26th best team in the NBA (they had the Nets in 28th) must mean that there were some extenuating circumstances, right?

Injuries to key players?

Nope. The team’s two ‘stars’ played more than 26 minutes each: Michael Porter Jr. (salary $40.8 million) and Julius Randle (salary $33.3 million). Egor Dëmin, the Nets highest draft pick for 15 years in the summer of 2025, started at shooting guard and played more than 31 minutes. Another member of the ‘Flatbush Five’, Nolan Traoré, started at point guard. Mikel Brown Jr., the sixth pick in the 2026 draft, came on as the sixth man and played more than 27 minutes. This was not a team made up of the men in places 14 to 18 on the roster – this was the best the Nets had.

Maybe the Nets are starting the earliest tank in NBA history, just to repeat the 2024/2025 and 2025/2026 seasons, and praying to the lottery gods?

Again, not quite. The Nets do not control their 2027 draft first-round pick (Houston can swap theirs with the Nets’ pick, after the 2021 James Harden trade – didn’t the Nets pay enough in taking on Ben Simmons?!), so there is no competitive advantage to be gained in the future from being shit today.

Is it all my fault?

Forget blaming Jordi Fernandez or Sean Marks – I fear this may be all my fault.

On 26 January 2023 I attended my first Nets game. In a 130 – 122 loss to the Detroit Pistons the starting five was Ben Simmons; Kyrie Irving; Joe Harris; Royce O’Neale and Nic Claxton. Kevin Durant was injured. Even though the Nets lost, Irving was the best player on the court by a mile.

Pre-game, Brooklyn Nets v Detroits Lions, January 2023
My image taken during the warm-up – Brooklyn Nets v Detroit Pistons, 26 January 2023

Eight days into my fandom, Irving requested a trade. Two days later, he was a Dallas Mavericks player. Three days after that, Kevin Durant was a Phoenix Suns player.

Eleven players got on to the court for the Nets in the game that I watched. Three of them left within 14 days. Seven of them were gone by 15 July. If you buy a Nets jersey with a player’s name on the back, it could become a vintage jersey within the week.

I’ve already seen six incarnations of the Nets:

  • about five seconds of the Durant and Irving led team in 2023;
  • the Mikal Bridges / Cameron Johnson / Dorian Finney-Smith / Spencer Dinwiddie 2023/2024 team;
  • the Dennis Schröder 2024 team;
  • the 2024/2025 tanking team;
  • the five first-round picks 2025/2026 team; and
  • the 2026/2027 sixth pick / Porter Jr. / Randle team.

That’s a lot of change in three and a half years. The Nets last made the play-offs in the 2022/2023 season – they lost 4-0 in the first-round to a Joel Embiid led Philadelphia 76ers who bullied Nic Claxton. They have not won a play-off game since 15 June 2021, that record may have a few years to go yet.

I am beginning to think that the greatest contribution anyone could make to the Nets’ rebuild is not Sean Marks drafting or trading his way to success or Jordi Fernandez developing a young team – it is simply me becoming a Knicks fan. Within a fortnight, Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns would probably have demanded trades, the Knicks would be falling apart, and Danny Wolf would have turned into a 22-year-old Michael Jordan.

Kyrie Irving playing for the Brooklyn Nets against the Cleveland Cavaliers on 17 January 2022.
Kyrie Irving in action for the Brooklyn Nets in January 2022, a year before his departure to the Dallas Mavericks. Photo: Erik Drost / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0.

So, What is Going Wrong?

After bringing in a wheelbarrow full of draft picks from outgoing trades for Kyrie Irving (one first-round pick); Kevin Durant (four first-round picks and one swap); and Mikal Bridges (five first-round picks and one swap), the Nets used five first-round picks in 2025, the sixth first-round pick in 2026, one other first-round pick (via a trade) and a second-round pick.

YearRoundPickPlayerPosition
20251st8Egor DëminGuard
20251st19Nolan TraoréGuard
20251st22Drake PowellGuard / Forward
20251st26Ben SarafGuard
20251st27Danny WolfForward / Centre
20261st8Mikel Brown Jr.Guard
20261st28Joshua JeffersonForward
20262nd43Tyler BilodeauForward

Today, the roster is built around the five 2025 picks, Mikel Brown Jr. and the comparative veterans of Michael Porter Jr., Julius Randle and Terence Mann.

In 2025 the Nets went for quantity over quality – should they have used five first-round picks? Maybe not.

Between 2000 and 2022, only three players out of the 69 drafted at 22, 26 or 27 have become All-Stars – 4.3%. Powell, Saraf and Wolf are likely to, at best, turn into good roster players – not stars. It is impossible to know but after one year of those three, it feels like trading those three picks for, say, one single pick in the top 10 in 2025 or 2026 would have been preferable.

When Dëmin was picked at 8 he was the franchise’s highest pick in the Brooklyn era. Naturally, that made expectations and excitement high, but there is the reality that no 8th pick has made an All-Star team this century – he is not guaranteed to be a star.

Amazingly, the 19th pick has found more stars between 2000 and 2022, three (13%) have made an All-Star team. On current evidence, Dëmin and maybe one other will turn into a solid NBA player. Statistically, it would be more of a surprise if any of them became an All-Star, rather than not.

How did Recent Champions Construct Their Rosters?

Let’s take the most recent winners and the Nets’ neighbours – the New York Knicks. When you look at their winning team, they did not draft their way to success. They built almost entirely through trades and free agency, and did it relatively quickly:

Starting Five versus San Antonio Spurs – Game Five NBA Finals – 13 June 2026
PlayerDetails
Jalen BrunsonSigned as a free agent in July 2022
Karl-Anthony TownsTraded in September 2024. Acquired KAT along with the draft rights for one player. Sent three players and one first-round pick to the Minnesota Timberwolves; and three players and two second-round picks to the Charlotte Hornets
OG AnnoyTraded in December 2023. Acquired Anunoby along with two other players from the Toronto Raptors. Sent two players and a second-round pick in the other direction.
Mikal BridgesTraded in July 2024. Acquired Bridges along with one other player from the Nets. Sent three players, five first-round picks, one first-round pick swap, and one second-round pick in return.
Josh HartTraded in February 2023. A convoluted trade that eventually involved the Portland Trailblazers, Philadelphia 76ers and Charlotte Hornets. Three players and first-round pick left the Knicks.

All of their winning starting five were acquired between July 2022 and September 2024, not one of them was drafted by the Knicks – things can change very quickly in the NBA.

Rather than the Knicks, maybe the previous 2024/2025 champions, Oklahoma City Thunder, are the Nets’ inspiration. OKC took a very different approach to the Knicks, and one that should give us Nets fans some hope.

They won the NBA championship just three years after finishing the 2021/2022 season with 24 wins and 58 losses (remember the 2024/2025 Nets – 26 wins and 56 losses). Their rebuild began in 2019, when they traded Paul George to the Los Angeles Clippers in return for Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, Danilo Gallinari, five first-round picks and two first-round pick swaps. They also traded Russell Westbrook to the Houston Rockets that summer, dismantling their established team in much the same way that Brooklyn would do four years later.

The Paul George trade proved to be an extraordinary piece of business. Gilgeous-Alexander developed into one of the best players in the NBA, winning both the regular-season MVP and Finals MVP awards in 2025. One of the first-round picks acquired from the Clippers was used to select Jalen Williams 12th overall in 2022, who also became an All-Star. The Nets have to hope that we can look back at the Mikal Bridges trade in the same way in the not too distant future.

That same summer, OKC used its own second pick to select Chet Holmgren – this is where the luck of the draw comes into it. OKC went 24-58 in 2021/2022, came second bottom of the Western Conference and came out of the lottery with the second pick – they had a 12.23% chance of receiving that pick.

In 2025/2026, the Nets went 20-62: a worse record than the 2021/2022 OKC team. The Nets had a 13.4% chance in the lottery of winning the second pick (better odds than OKC had in 2022). What happened? They got the sixth pick.

OKC and the Nets both spent millions on their roster and had vast scouting and analytic teams in the background poring over college games all year round. No amount of scouting instinct or computer algorithms could fix the fact that the Nets came out of the lottery and had to pick Mikel Brown Jr. rather than Darryn Peterson.

Three of the five starters in the OKC championship-winning Game Seven team against Indiana were either drafted by OKC or acquired through the Paul George trade. The other two were Luguentz Dort, who went undrafted in 2019, and Isaiah Hartenstein, signed as a free agent in 2024.

The Thunder won 22 games in 2020/2021, 24 the following season, 40 in 2022/2023, 57 in 2023/2024 and 68 in their championship-winning 2024/2025 season. In just three years, they went from one of the worst teams in the NBA to one of the best. Importantly, they didn’t simply rely on their young players developing. Once their core was established, they supplemented it with experienced players, notably Hartenstein and Alex Caruso, who arrived in a trade with the Chicago Bulls in 2024.

There is, however, one important distinction between OKC’s rebuild and Brooklyn’s. When the Thunder began losing heavily, they already had Gilgeous-Alexander, a player who would develop into a genuine superstar – will Dëmin, Brown Jr. or one of the first-round picks that the Nets have over the next five years do the same?

Part of me thinks that the Knicks took the more sensible approach. Rather than waiting years to see whether speculative draft picks would turn into good NBA players, they used those picks to acquire players who had already demonstrated what they could do.

When they traded for Karl-Anthony Towns they knew they were getting a 7’0 giant who had spent nine seasons in the NBA averaging around 22 points per game, 11 rebounds and who had started at least 50 regular season games in seven of his nine seasons with the Minnesota Timberwolves (as Charles Barkley often says, availability is one of the best abilities).

Along with some players, they gave up one future first-round pick. A pick that they could not guarantee where it would fall and what that particular draft class would look like (2023 first pick, Victor Wembanyama; 2024 first pick, Zaccharie Risacher).

They correctly, in my view, valued KAT over the potential of drafting a player who may be very good in five years’ time.

Has Sean Marks Actually Done a Good Job?

Sean Marks has been the Nets’ general manager since February 2016. That’s more than ten years in charge, which is a very long time in professional sport, particularly when the team you are responsible for has not won a play-off game in more than five years. So, how much responsibility should he take for Brooklyn’s current position?

To be fair to Marks, he inherited a dreadful situation. The Nets had famously surrendered much of their future draft capital to the Boston Celtics in the disastrous 2013 trade for Kevin Garnett and Paul Pierce, leaving him with an ageing team and very little opportunity to rebuild through the draft. Within three years, he had turned Brooklyn into an attractive enough destination that Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving both agreed to join in 2019. For a franchise that had spent much of its existence in the shadow of the Knicks, that was quite an achievement.

Of course, things didn’t quite work out as planned. The arrival of James Harden in 2021 was supposed to create a team that could dominate the NBA, but it instead resulted in the Nets surrendering another enormous collection of draft picks for a player who lasted just 80 regular-season games. The subsequent departures of Harden, Irving and Durant left the Nets having to rebuild again. It would be unfair to blame Marks entirely for three superstars deciding that they no longer wanted to play together, but he was the man who assembled the team in the first place and authorised the enormous gamble on Harden (when Harden left, getting in Ben Simmons who couldn’t stay fit for more than ten minutes to replace him was an unmitigated disaster).

Since then, Marks has demonstrated that he is rather good at extracting draft capital from other franchises. The Durant and Bridges trades have left Brooklyn with enough future selections to make almost any other general manager envious. But accumulating picks is only half the job. His recent record in actually selecting players is less convincing, and the decision to take five players in the first round of the 2025 draft is one that I suspect will be scrutinised for years to come.

There is a distinction between putting a franchise in a position where it might be successful in the future (big tick) and actually making it successful (big cross). Ten years after his appointment, I think it is reasonable to expect rather more than another promising collection of draft rights and assurances that the future is bright. At some point, the success of a general manager has to be measured by the team he puts on the court, rather than the number of assets he has accumulated off it.

Sean Marks, general manager of the Brooklyn Nets, speaking during a season-ending interview in April 2025.
Sean Marks, the Brooklyn Nets’ general manager since February 2016, discussing the franchise’s future in April 2025. Image: YES Network / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 3.0.

Are There any Positives for the Nets?

Despite everything that has gone wrong, there are two very good reasons for Nets fans to be optimistic about the future: the franchise’s financial position and its enormous collection of draft rights.

Cap space

The Nets currently have the lowest player payroll in the NBA, at approximately $160 million, against a salary cap of $165 million. That leaves relatively little room to spend this season, but the position could change considerably.

In the summer of 2027, the projected NBA salary cap is $176 million, while Brooklyn currently has around $119 million committed to player salaries for the 2027/2028 season. Depending on decisions about existing contracts, free agents and draft picks, the Nets could have close to $70 million available to spend, without being close to the luxury tax or either of the aprons.

Much will depend on what happens to Michael Porter Jr., whose $40.8 million annual contract expires at the end of this season, and Julius Randle, who has a $35.8 million player option for 2027/2028. Retaining both would significantly reduce the available money. Between the two of them today, they earn just over 46% of the Nets’ team payroll.

To put $70 million in context – Steph Curry is the highest NBA earner this season with a salary just over $62.5 million.

Draft rights

In his summer 2026 assessment, ESPN’s Bobby Marks placed Brooklyn in the highest tier for draft assets, alongside Oklahoma City, Memphis, Charlotte and several others.

Draft rights in the next five summers:

YearRoundDetails
20271stTheir own (but Houston Rockets can swap it with their pick)
20271stVia New York Knicks
20272ndVia the Los Angeles Lakers (not guaranteed)
20281stTheir own
20281stVia Philadelphia 76ers
20282ndTheir own
20282ndVia Atlanta Hawks
20282ndVia Memphis Grizzlies
20291stTheir own
20291stVia New York Knicks
20291stVia Dallas Mavericks / Phoenix Suns / Houston Rockets – the Nets receive the least favourable
20292ndTheir own
20292ndVia Dallas Mavericks
20292ndVia Golden State Warriors
20292ndVia Memphis Grizzlies
20301stTheir own
20302ndTheir own
20302ndVia Boston Celtics
20302ndVia Dallas Mavericks
20302ndVia the Los Angeles Clippers
20311stTheir own
20311stVia New York Knicks
20312ndTheir own
20312ndVia the Los Angeles Clippers

There are restrictions and conditions attached to some of these selections, but few NBA franchises can match Brooklyn’s collection of draft capital. However, it’s not as simple as saying ‘having the most first-round picks mean you have the best draft capital’. The Nets have three of the Knicks first round picks in 2027, 2029 and 2031. If the Knicks continue to challenge at the top and consistently make the play-offs these draft rights will not result in any top ten picks. If the Nets decided to give up any of these picks in trades the team on the other side of the trade will know this too, and will value those picks accordingly – not all first-round picks are equal.

What Could They Do With Their Cash and Draft Rights?

Spend in free agency

Free cap space has the most value in free agency – if Gilgeous-Alexander had a contract that expired this summer all of the NBA would want him, but very few could afford him within the confines of the cap.

The 2027 free-agent class could be exceptionally strong. A number of top players (Nikola Jokić; Giannis Antetokounmpo and Karl-Anthony Towns, to name only three) have the power in their hands with ‘player options’ – meaning they can choose to exercise a right to remain for one more year, and their franchise can do nothing about it if they decide not to.

The Nets will have the cap space for Jokic or Antetokounmpo (and would not have to give up any draft capital for either of them), but what are the chances of either of those two 32-year-olds choosing to move to the Nets in 2027? Unlikely today, but stranger things have happened.

Zach LaVine could also become unrestricted free agent in the summer of 2027. Getting in someone like him on a salary that still gives the Nets flexibility within the cap would be an interesting move.

Opportunities could come as players on rookie contracts become eligible for big contract extensions. Take the San Antonio Spurs – there will likely come a time where both Victor Wembanyama and Dylan Harper want maximum salary contract extensions. The Spurs could do this, but will likely have to say goodbye to a couple of very good basketball players in order to have Wembanyama, Harper, and thirteen other good players, all within the confines of the cap. The same could happen with OKC; Gilgeous-Alexander, Jalen Williams and Chet Holmgren are only going to get more expensive. On their current contracts, those three will earn more than $185 million between them in 2030/2031 season.

The current salary-cap rules make it increasingly expensive and restrictive for good teams to keep their rosters together long term, particularly once they cross the luxury-tax threshold and the two aprons. There will inevitably be opportunities for Brooklyn to acquire players whose existing franchises are finding it difficult to justify keeping them.

Trade

If the Nets conclude that none of their recent draft selections is going to develop into a superstar, they could potentially use their money and draft capital to acquire one instead. That would be closer to the approach taken by their neighbours across the East River.

At the pre-season media day in September, Sean Marks was asked if he would ‘push all the chips to the middle of the table’ for a player who would change the trajectory of the franchise. He dodged the question slightly, but did say that ‘I can’t predict when players from other teams become available’, before asking ‘when’s the right time to go for this?’.

In November 2026, Sam Amick of The Athletic reported that the Nets were prepared to listen to trade offers for anyone on their roster. I suppose everyone has a price. Michael Porter Jr. and Julius Randle are interesting because both are established players who could potentially help a championship contender immediately, but neither is realistically part of Brooklyn’s long-term plans. They are the equivalent of a 2025 Cam Johnson.

Brooklyn has some experience of using draft capital to acquire a franchise leading player – could they be once bitten, twice shy? In January 2021, the Nets acquired James Harden from the Houston Rockets, surrendering three first-round draft picks, four first-round pick swaps and several players. Harden played just 80 regular-season games for Brooklyn before being traded to Philadelphia in February 2022. The consequences of that original trade continued for years – Houston can still swap first-round picks with Brooklyn in 2027.

That doesn’t mean the Nets should be frightened of making another major trade. But there is an important difference between acquiring one of the best players in the NBA and paying the price of one of the best players in the NBA for somebody who is merely very good. Arguably, that is exactly what the Knicks did when they acquired Mikal Bridges.

At some point, Sean Marks will have to push his chips into the middle of the table – he just needs to do it with two aces up his sleeve, not two-four off suit.

(Continue to) Draft

The third option is perhaps the least exciting: do nothing particularly dramatic. The Nets could simply keep their draft picks, continue selecting young players and hope that, eventually, they find a superstar.

They could even go one step further and trade away Porter Jr., Randle and Mann for additional draft picks. Brooklyn could also use its available salary-cap space to take on expensive contracts that other teams are desperate to get rid of, receiving draft picks as compensation. It might make financial sense, but committing to another few years of losing basketball games would be a very difficult sell when it came to season ticket renewals.

The practical problem with accumulating an ever-increasing number of draft picks is obvious: an NBA team can only have 15 players on standard contracts, and there are only 240 minutes of playing time to distribute in each game. The Nets have already brought in eight players through the last two drafts, all of whom need opportunities to demonstrate whether they are good enough to play in the NBA. If Brooklyn adds another two or three young players every summer, how are they all supposed to develop?

At some point, the franchise will have to decide which prospects are worth keeping and which are better used as trade assets. To be fair, they have already ditched two of three players they drafted in 2023.

There is also a halfway house between using every draft pick and trading them all away for established players. As I argued earlier, perhaps Brooklyn would have been better off combining some of its later first-round picks in 2025 to try to move higher up the draft. They could adopt that approach in future years, using their enormous collection of selections to target a smaller number of players whom their scouts believe have genuine superstar potential.

There is always another draft, another exciting teenager and another reason to be optimistic about the future. But I am not sure I could stomach another three or four years of being told how promising the Nets are going to be in three or four years’ time.

What Should Count as Success This Season?

Nobody expected the Nets to challenge for the NBA championship this season, but surely there has to be something between winning the championship and losing 60 basketball games?

For the previous two seasons, there was at least an argument that tanking served a purpose, even if the lottery didn’t work out particularly well. That incentive has disappeared this season, with Houston able to swap its first-round pick with Brooklyn’s. There is no consolation in finishing with the worst record in the NBA if another franchise ends up benefiting from it.

I don’t think the Nets necessarily need to make the play-offs for this season to be considered progress (on present evidence, they won’t get close anyway). If they could win 30 games rather than 20, establish a reasonably consistent starting five and demonstrate that Dëmin, Brown Jr. and some of the other young players are improving, that would be a meaningful step forward. More important than the number of wins might be whether, by April 2027, we have a clearer idea of which players are going to be part of the team in three years’ time.

This is also where I have some sympathy for Jordi Fernández. There is only so much a coach can do when he has been given a constantly changing roster consisting largely of young players who are still learning how to play in the NBA. He cannot suddenly turn a collection of promising 20-year-olds into a championship-winning team, irrespective of how good his coaching might be. Nevertheless, he can be judged on whether the players are improving, whether the team is organised and whether Brooklyn is becoming more competitive as the season progresses.

The worry is that the Nets could reach the end of another season with 20-something wins and still have no clearer idea of who their best players are. In the grand scheme of things, they would be a much greater disappointment than simply being rubbish for a season, again.

Conclusion – So, Whose Fault Is It?

I don’t think there is one person who can be blamed for the Nets’ current predicament. The collapse of the Durant, Irving and Harden experiment was partly the result of decisions taken by the franchise and partly the result of circumstances that nobody could have entirely predicted. The lottery hasn’t been particularly kind to Brooklyn either, although there is only so much sympathy I can have for a team complaining that its reward for being dreadful wasn’t quite as good as it had hoped.

Jordi Fernández has a difficult job, but the principal responsibility must rest with Sean Marks. He has been in charge for more than a decade and has overseen both the assembly and dismantling of two very different Nets teams, and lots of other groups of players that you could loosely call a ‘team’ in between and since. He has the resources to do something about Brooklyn’s predicament, and has several different ways of going about it. The next few years will determine whether he is remembered as the man who rescued the Nets from the collapse of the Durant and Irving era, or the man who presided over a decade of ultimately unsuccessful rebuilding.

I would like to think that I will eventually get to watch the Nets win a play-off game. I would settle for watching them win a few more regular-season games at the moment.

And if it all goes wrong again, I am prepared to accept my share of the blame – but I think Sean Marks should probably go first.

Other Sport Articles to read


Discover more from The Penwarden Review

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply